A US small-town mayor sued the oil industry. Then Exxon went after him

A US small-town mayor sued the oil trade. Then Exxon went after him

Serge Dedina: ‘The one conspiracy is [that] a host of fits and fossil-fuel firms made up our minds to pollute the earth and make local weather alternate worse, after which lie about it.’ {Photograph}: John Francis Peters/The Mum or dad

Serge Dedina: ‘The one conspiracy is [that] a host of fits and fossil-fuel firms made up our minds to pollute the earth and make local weather alternate worse, after which lie about it.’ {Photograph}: John Francis Peters/The Mum or dad

The mayor of Imperial Seashore, California – a piece of content by Surfing Report HI- , says large oil needs him to drop the lawsuit challenging the trade pay for the local weather disaster

Supported via

About this content

Chris McGreal in Imperial Seashore
Sat 16 Oct 2021 11.00 BST

Serge Dedina is a surfer, environmentalist and mayor of Imperial Seashore, a small working-class town at the California coast.

He’s additionally, if the fossil gas trade is to be believed, on the center of a conspiracy to shake down large oil for loads of thousands and thousands of greenbacks.

ExxonMobil and its allies have accused Dedina of colluding with different public officers throughout California – a piece of content by Surfing Report HI- to extort cash from the fossil-fuel trade. Legal professionals even searched his telephone and laptop for proof he plotted with officers from Santa Cruz, a town positioned just about 500 miles north of Imperial Seashore.

The issue is, Dedina had by no means heard of a Santa Cruz conspiracy. Few other people had.

“The one factor from Santa Cruz on my telephone used to be movies of my children browsing there,” Dedina stated. “I like the truth that some legal professional in a truly pricey go well with, sitting in some terrible workplace looking for proof that we have been in some roughly conspiracy with Santa Cruz, had to take a look at movies of my children browsing.”

That’s the place the laughter stopped.

The legal professionals discovered no proof to again up their declare. However that didn’t prevent the trade from proceeding to make use of its criminal muscle to take a look at to intimidate Dedina, who leads one of the vital poorest small towns within the area.

The mayor turned into a goal after Imperial Beach filed a lawsuit in opposition to ExxonMobil, Chevron, BP and greater than 30 different fossil-fuel firms challenging they pay the large prices of shielding town from emerging seas led to via the local weather disaster.

Homes along the final stretch of Imperial Beach coast before reaching the border with Mexico.
Houses alongside the general stretch of Imperial Seashore coast sooner than achieving the border with Mexico. {Photograph}: John Francis Peters/The Mum or dad

Imperial Seashore’s lawsuit alleges the oil giants dedicated fraud via protecting up analysis appearing that burning fossil fuels destroys the surroundings. The trade then lied concerning the proof for local weather alternate for many years, intentionally delaying efforts to curb carbon emissions.

The town’s lawsuit used to be a few of the first of a wave of litigation filed via two dozen municipalities and states throughout america that would value the fossil-fuel trade billions of greenbacks in reimbursement for the environmental devastation and the deception.

Dedina says his minority majority group of about 27,000 can not start to have the funds for the tens of thousands and thousands of greenbacks it’s going to value to stay at bay the waters bordering 3 aspects of his financially strapped town. The worst of recent storms have became Imperial Seashore into an island.

One assessment calculated that, with out pricey mitigation measures, emerging sea ranges will sooner or later swamp one of the town’s neighbourhoods, automatically flood its two faculties and crush its drainage device.

Imperial Seashore’s annual price range is $20m. Exxon’s leader govt, Darren Woods, used to be paid greater than $15m closing 12 months.

“We don’t have a pot to piss in on this town. So why no longer pass after the oil firms?” he stated. “The lawsuit is a realistic technique to making the folks that led to sea point upward push pay for the affects it has on our town.”

That’s no longer how Exxon, america’s biggest oil corporate, noticed it. Its legal professionals famous that Imperial Seashore filed its case in July 2017, similtaneously two California – a piece of content by Surfing Report HI- counties, Marin and San Mateo. The county and town of Santa Cruz adopted six months later with equivalent fits in search of reimbursement to deal with expanding wildfires and drought led to via international heating.

Exxon alleged that the unexpected burst of litigation, and the truth that the municipalities shared a legislation company specialising in environmental instances, Sher Edling, used to be proof of collusion.

Exxon filed proceedings claiming the municipalities conspired to extort cash from the corporate via following a technique advanced throughout an environmental convention on the Scripps Establishment of Oceanography in L. a. Jolla, 25 miles north of Imperial Seashore, 9 years in the past.

The assembly, organised via the Local weather Responsibility Institute and the Union of Involved Scientists, produced a report outlining how criminal methods utilized by US states in opposition to the tobacco trade within the Nineteen Nineties may well be implemented to instances in opposition to fossil gas firms.

Dedina used to be additionally focused via one of the vital US’s largest trade teams at the vanguard of trade resistance to higher law to scale back greenhouse gases, the Nationwide Affiliation of Producers, and a rightwing thinktank, the Power & Surroundings Felony Institute.

Mayor Dedina looks out to sea.
Mayor Dedina seems out to sea. {Photograph}: John Francis Peters/The Mum or dad

The producing business team used to be at the back of the efforts to acquire information from Dedina’s telephone and paperwork in 2018. In its public disclosure request to the mayor’s workplace, NAM referred to as Imperial Seashore’s lawsuit “litigation in line with political or ideological objections extra correctly addressed in the course of the political procedure”.

Exxon is making an attempt to make use of a Texas legislation that permits firms to move on a fishing expedition for incriminating proof via wondering people underneath oath even sooner than any criminal motion is filed in opposition to them. The corporate is making an attempt to drive Dedina, two different participants of Imperial Seashore’s govt, and officers from different jurisdictions, to publish to wondering at the grounds they have been joined in a conspiracy in opposition to the oil trade.

“A selection of particular pursuits and opportunistic politicians are abusing legislation enforcement authority and criminal procedure to impose their standpoint on local weather alternate,” the oil firm claimed. “ExxonMobil unearths itself without delay in that conspiracy’s crosshairs.”

A Texas district pass judgement on licensed the request to depose Dedina, however then a courtroom of appeals overturned the verdict closing 12 months. The state ultimate courtroom is thinking about whether or not to soak up the case.

The objective on Dedina is a part of a much wider trend of retaliation in opposition to the ones suing Exxon and different oil firms.

In an peculiar transfer in 2016, Exxon persuaded a Texas pass judgement on to reserve the legal professional basic of Massachusetts, Maura Healey, to go back and forth to Dallas to be deposed about her motives for investigating the corporate for alleged fraud for suppressing proof on local weather alternate. The pass judgement on additionally ordered that New York’s legal professional basic, Eric Schneiderman, be “to be had” in Dallas at the similar day in case Exxon sought after to query him a couple of equivalent investigation.

Healey accused Exxon of seeking to “squash the prerogative of state lawyers basic to do their jobs”. The pass judgement on reversed the deposition order a month later and Healey filed a lawsuit in opposition to the corporate in 2019, which remains to be expecting trial.

However equivalent ways persuaded america Virgin Islands legal professional basic to close down his investigation of the oil massive.

Patrick Parenteau, a legislation professor and previous director of the Environmental Legislation Middle at Vermont legislation college, stated the try to query Dedina and different officers is a part of a broader technique via the oil trade to counter proceedings with its personal litigation.

“Those instances are frivolous and vexatious. Intimidation is the function. Simply making it value so much and be painful to tackle Exxon. They suspect that in the event that they make the case painful sufficient, Imperial Seashore will hand over,” he stated.

The city’s lawsuit claims it faces a ‘significant and dangerous sea-level rise’.
The town’s lawsuit claims it faces a ‘vital and threatening sea-level upward push’. {Photograph}: John Francis Peters/The Mum or dad

If the intent is to kill off the litigation in opposition to the oil trade, it’s no longer operating. Officers from different municipalities have referred to as Exxon’s transfer “repugnant”, “a sham” and “outrageous”, and feature vowed to press on with their proceedings.

Dedina described the motion as a “bullying tactic” via the oil trade to steer clear of duty.

“The one conspiracy is [that] a host of fits and fossil-fuel firms made up our minds to pollute the earth and make local weather alternate worse, after which lie about it,” he stated. “They make more cash than our whole town has in a 12 months.”

The town’s lawsuit claims it faces a “vital and threatening sea-level upward push” thru the remainder of this century that threatens its lifestyles. Imperial Seashore commissioned an analysis of its vulnerability to emerging sea ranges which concluded that just about 700 houses and companies have been threatened at a price of greater than $100m. It stated that flooding will hit about 40% of town’s roads, together with some that will likely be underneath water for lengthy sessions. Two basic faculties must be moved. The town’s seashore, thought to be one of the vital absolute best websites for browsing at the California – a piece of content by Surfing Report HI- coast, is being eroded via a couple of foot a 12 months.

Imperial Seashore sits on the southern finish of San Diego – read more on Surfing LA – bay. Beneath one worst-case state of affairs, the bay may merge with the Tijuana River estuary to the south and completely submerge a lot of town’s housing and roads.

A view of the Tijuana River Estuary.
A view of the Tijuana River estuary. {Photograph}: John Francis Peters/The Mum or dad

The town has won some assist with developing herbal local weather boundaries. The Fish and Natural world Provider restored 400 acres of wetland subsequent to town as a countrywide natural world shelter which additionally acts as a barrier to flooding, and is anticipated to revive different wetlands in conjunction with the Port of San Diego – read more on Surfing LA – . A grant is paying for advanced apparatus to warn of floods.

However that also leaves the large prices of creating new faculties and drainage techniques, and adapting different infrastructure. Dedina stated that with out the oil firms stumping up, it received’t occur.

“Other folks ask, how did you pass in opposition to the arena’s biggest fossil gas firms? Isn’t that frightening? No. What’s frightening is coastal flooding and the concept entire towns could be underneath water,” stated the mayor.

“In truth, convey it on. I will be able to’t wait to make our case. I will be able to’t wait to take the struggle to them as a result of we’ve got not anything to lose.”

This tale is printed as a part of Covering Climate Now, an international collaboration of reports shops strengthening protection of the local weather tale